Sandlot
Shrink Mock Draft #2
By Bob Radl, staff writer
August 4, 2009
|
Round |
team 1 |
team 2 |
team 3 |
team 4 |
team 5 |
team 6 |
team 7 |
team 8 |
team 9 |
team 10 |
team 11 |
team 12 |
|
|
1 |
A.Peterson |
Jones-Drew |
S.Jackson |
M.
Turner |
Matt
Forte |
Chr.
Johnson |
Tomlinson |
L.Fitzgerald |
DeA.
Williams |
R.
Moss |
Calv.Johnson |
A.Johnson |
|
|
2 |
Kevin
Smith |
Ronny
Brown |
Tom Brady |
R.Wayne |
P.Manning |
Westbrook |
M.Barber |
C.Portis |
Brand.Jacobs |
Steve
Slaton |
Drew Brees |
Frank
Gore |
|
|
3 |
G.Jennings |
Roddy
White |
M.Colston |
Pierre
Thomas |
A.
Bolden |
Ryan
Grant |
T.Owens |
D.Bowe |
Kurt
Warner |
V.
Jackson |
Marsh.Lynch |
Rodgers |
|
|
4 |
B.Edwards |
Matt Ryan |
McFadden |
Bran.Marshall |
Thomas
Jones |
Tony Romo |
Houshmanz |
Roy
Williams |
Steve
Smith |
Philip
Rivers |
Wes
Welker |
Ochocinco |
|
|
5 |
Lee
Evans |
Derrick
Ward |
Sant.Holmes |
Jason
Witten |
Torry
Holt |
Eddie
Royal |
A.Gonzalez |
Know.Moreno* |
S.
Moss |
DeS.Jackson |
L.Johnson |
W.Parker |
|
|
6 |
Jay Cutler |
Carson
Palmer |
B.Berrian |
Kevin
Walter |
Chris
Henry |
D.Mason |
Matt
Schaub |
D.McNabb |
Antonio
Bryant |
Ant.Gates |
T.Gonzalez |
Chris
Wells* |
|
|
7 |
O.Daniels |
Breaston |
Dallas
Clark |
Hasselbeck |
J.Addai |
D.Driver |
Greg
Olsen |
Julius
Jones |
Chris
Cooley |
Reggie
Bush |
Cotchery |
K.Winslow |
|
|
8 |
E.Manning |
Justin
Gage |
Roeth'berger |
Garrard |
John
Carlson |
Lance
Moore |
Hines
Ward |
Zach
Miller |
Matt
Cassell |
C.Benson |
Crabtree* |
L.Coles |
|
|
9 |
Ray
Rice |
Engram |
Donnie
Avery |
Jon.
Stewart |
Ted
Ginn |
T.Edwards |
Felix
Jones |
Devin
Hester |
Kevin
Curtis |
Dom.Hixon |
Joe Flacco |
Percy
Harvin* |
|
|
10 |
P.Crayton |
Kevin
Boss |
Don.
Brown* |
Chambers |
Rackers |
Kaeding |
Crosby |
Delhomme |
Akers |
Gostkowski |
Mendenhall |
Kyle Orton |
|
|
11 |
Bironas |
Brent
Celek |
Elam |
Kris
Brown |
J.Campbell |
Dustin
Keller |
Brady
Quinn |
Hartley |
Hightower |
Shiancoe |
Folk |
J.Shockey |
|
|
12 |
Pope |
Kasay |
M.
Lewis |
Bo
Scaife |
Pettigrew* |
Vern
Davis |
McMichael |
Heath
Miller |
Scheffler |
Pennington |
Fasano |
Longwell |
|
|
bonus |
Sh.Greene* |
LeS.
McCoy* |
McGahee |
LenDale
White |
Branch |
Galloway |
Jamal
Lewis |
Bradshaw |
D.Sproles |
M.
Bush |
Josh
Morgan |
Chester
Taylor |
|
|
bonus |
Coffey* |
Mannignham |
Mark
Bradley |
Rosenfels |
T.
Choice |
Jenkins |
R.Meachem |
Steve
Smith |
Fargas |
Miles
Austin |
Fred
Taylor |
Mark
Clayton |
|
|
bonus |
K.
Britt* |
Jam.
Russell |
Hakeem
Nicks* |
B.
Robiskie* |
Burleson |
Buckhalter |
Fred
Jackson |
Jam.
Charles |
Randle
El |
Higgins |
Br.
Jackson |
N.Washington |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Scoring is the same as our rankings. We choose no defenses and ignore bye weeks and receiver receptions to keep it simple. You must fill out your roster prior to the bonus rounds where you can pick any position you want.
Quarterbacks listed in black (2)
Running backs listed in blue (3)
Wide receivers listed in red (4)
Tight ends listed in green (2)
Kickers listed in italics (1)
* = Rookies
The August draft had many of the same managers returning that were in
attendance for the late May draft. We also had some new faces with different
strategies.
We had four WR being drafted in round one as teams were trying to avoid
first round busts and went with high profile receivers late in the first round.
Since this draft is not a point per reception (PPR) league, the value of WR
is downgraded to some degree. Many teams took a top flight QB as early in as
the second or third round also due to the scoring system being used. So please
keep this in mind when looking at the results and considering the nuances of
your own league and its scoring method. I would also like to look at the first
three picks on some of the teams as this sets the tone for the balance of the
draft.
Team #1….Adrian Peterson continues to go #1 overall, especially in yardage
and touchdown leagues. Kevin Smith was a bit of a surprise at the end of the
second round but understandable given our scoring rules. Braylon Edwards will
need to regain his Pro-bowl form for this team to contend. Jay Cutler had nice
value in the 8th round. Ray Rice was a great pick in the 9th
round as he is normally being drafted in the middle of the 7th round
in most mock drafts. This team opened with RB-RB-WR. This is good basic plan
for yardage and touchdown leagues. You should get nice value for your first
three picks and set yourself up for the remainder of the draft.
Team #2….Took it’s back up QB too early and left a huge hole at WR as Steve
Breaston was drafted as the WR2. The manager then quickly followed with two
more WR choices. The team has nice RB depth. LeSean McCoy has some upside as a
bonus pick. This is another choice of RB-RB-WR to start the draft.
Team #3…This team could be a contender if Darren McFadden plays stays
healthy and gets the required touches each week. Santonio Holmes has potential
that remains untapped at WR. Brady could once again be the best fantasy QB in
the league. Donald Brown was a nice pick in round ten. Willis McGahee will not
last until the 13th round in most drafts but did so given the
limitations of this draft. This team opened with RB-QB-WR. This should leave
you with a top tier player at each spot. You will need to get lucky with your
RB2 with this method of drafting but it can be done. Other good QBs can also be
drafted a round or two later.
Team #4…This team had a nice first five picks that were real solid. Kevin
Walter should be a decent WR3. The big concern on this squad will be the QB play.
Either Hasselbeck or Garrard will need to put up top ten or top 12 numbers to
be competitive. Pierre Thomas has some upside in round three but is still
unproven. Jonathan Stewart looks like good value in round 9. LenDale White, a
bonus pick here, will go much earlier in all draft formats and is generally
going in the 7th round in mock drafts.
Team #5…I liked the first four picks on this team. It appeared to be off to
a strong draft. But Holt and Henry were both taken too early. Holt is best as a
WR3 or WR4 for most squads. Chris Henry is still the WR3 for the Bengals but
does offer plenty of upside if he can ever play up to his ability. This manager
also opened with RB-QB-WR and did get a top player at each spot. Deion Branch
and Tashard Choice were nice bonus picks.
Team #6…The wide receiver play of this squad will determine its fate for the
year. Nice trio of RBs to start the draft. Trent Edwards was a nice pick in the
9th round as was Lance Moore in round 8. This is the classic stud RB
theory that can work if properly executed. But you need to get very luck at
either QB or WR to do well in your league. The RB-RB-RB start is best only in
touchdown and yardage leagues as you lose out on the top flight WRs in PPR
leagues.
Team #7….I liked the first seven picks on this team as they appear to be
very solid. This appears to be one of the stronger squads on paper. LT will
need to return to form though. Matt Schaub will need to stay healthy all
year as well. Robert Meachem and Fred Jackson offer nice upside from the bonus
rounds. Once again, RB-RB-WR to start the draft.
Team #8…This team has the best trio of WR and would score well in a PPR
league. The RB play will determine the fate of this squad. Two of the three top
RBs will need to perform well and stay healthy. Zach Miller was a nice TE
choice in round 8. Devin Hester makes for a nice WR 4 but may not be needed.
The bonus picks were decent but not great. This manager opened with WR-RB-WR.
This type of a start would be quite normal for teams at the end of the first
round. You open with a top WR and then try and get value with your RB choices
later on. I would suggest that if you start with WR-RB-WR, then you chose a RB2
in the fourth round unless you feel lucky mining for an RB2 in the fifth round
or later.
Team #9…..This team worked the draft board well as Steve Smith from Carolina
somehow was overlooked until the fourth round. This is not likely to happen
again….so be forewarned. The first four picks look real solid. Santana Moss and
Antonio Bryant will need to perform at a high level to contend. Matt Cassell
has decent potential to cover for Warner if he gets hurt. This team opened with
RB-RB-QB in the first three rounds. This gives you two good RBs to start the
draft plus a top flight QB. The key to this strategy is then getting WR value
in the rest of the draft. The aforementioned Steve Smith fell into his lap.
This strategy works best in leagues that emphasize the RB and QB in the scoring
format.
Team #10….The fortunes of this squad will rest on its RB play from Reggie
Bush and Cedric Benson. Steve Slaton will also need to stay healthy. Nice trio
of WR on this squad that might be better suited for a PPR league. Michael Bush
offers some upside, as does Miles Austin from the bonus rounds. This team also
used the WR-RB-WR choice to open the draft. This strategy is best suited for
the PPR leagues and teams drafting late in the first round.
Team #11….The RB play on this squad will determine the fate of this team.
Calvin Johnson and Drew Brees made for a nice 1-2 punch to start the draft. Wes
Welker is solid and golden in a PPR league. Welker should score this year with
Tom Brady back under center. This team opened with WR-QB-RB for the draft. This
strategy works best once again in a PPR league and is also used by teams at the
end of the first round. The weakness is not getting a RB2 until round three so
you will need to land a player or two with great upside.
Team #12…..Drafting at the end of the first round is always an interesting
quandary for a manager. Some like those back-to-back picks but also realize
that you will be waiting for what seems like an eternity before you draft
again. I liked the first four picks on this squad. Either Parker or Chris Wells
will need to step up as the RB2 for the team to contend. Percy Harvin from the
Vikings was an interesting choice in round nine and offers some upside if he
can stay out of trouble and healthy. Chester Taylor lasted until the bonus
rounds. This will not happen in your league. The owners of AP will want to
handcuff Taylor to AP by round 9 or 10 at the very latest.